Saturday, July 11, 2009

The Non Book Club

After our run on Friday, Patty and I were discussing ways to make this "book club" work for everyone. We realized that we really don't want it to be like a regular book club where we all read the same book, since we have such different tastes. What we thought would be better is getting together and sharing the books we have already read, sort of like our own library. Then as we're reading them or when we're done, we can comment on them to let others know what we liked and didn't like about the book. It will sort of be more of a book review than a book club. Since we are also sharing many of the same books, it will be easy for the rest of us to chime in and comment on them too.

So to get this thing started. . . .I am reading The 19th Wife by David Ebershoff. It's basically based on the true story of Brigham Young's 19th wife and a fictional character involved in a polygamist society. I'm still in the early stages of the book. It starts slowly, but I'm getting more into it. After reading Twilight, it's hard to switch gears into a more "serious" book with MUCH smaller print. The only thing I do not like about the book is how it jumps around so much. It goes back and forth from the true story to the fictional story to letters and stories written by other people. I'm not enjoying the fictional part of the story as much as the true story of Brigham Young's wife. Parts of it do have me hooked so I'll keep reading it and see what happens.

3 comments:

Patty said...

Ok I started reading Twilight last night and got to chapter 6. I am going to give my honest opinion, so hopefully I won't offend any true fans. First of all it is easy reading and not too hard to stick with. If I am being honest I have to say that I am not hooked on the storyline just yet. It seems like the author is trying to portray the female character as an outsider, a misfit in some ways, (her pale skin, her clumsiness) yet she has yet to sit alone at lunch, has three boys ask her to a dance, and catches the eye of an incredibly handsome boy (vampire, I guess). I don't feel sorry for her or identify with her at all, and I think the part that most teenage girls must like about it, is the forbidden love, and the fact that such a handsome, perfect boy could be attracted to her in the first place. It is supposed to give us all hope. I don't buy it though because it seems everyone is attracted to her, and I am not sure why. Are kids in high school as friendly as in the book (I don't think so)? Maybe in smaller towns. Anyway that is my opinion so far, I hope I can get into their, "I'm so attracted to you, but I can't have you" storyline. I hope my negativity doesn't keep anyone from reading it, I am only on chapter six, so I have hopes I will get swept up in it very soon. I am going to give it a good effort today.

marathon mom said...

You shouldn't expect it to be too realistic, just entertaining. Remember, it IS a story about vampires. None of it is real, but that's why it is fiction. Just like Harry Potter. How real is that, but look how many people love it and love the movies. I think the author was going for the Romeo and Juliet forbidden love thing and whether true love will conquer all, even if it is between a vampire and mortal. I liked it because it didn't require too deep of thought and it was quick and easy summer reading to distract me.

Patty said...

I think I should have waited to post my first opinion/review. I think I was in a mood, won't say what kind. I still am not crazy about the book but am about half way through and it is holding my interest. I am probably not in the target demographic for this book, but I can see why it would appeal to girls of a certain age, or older. I am having trouble reading anything and truly enjoying it lately, which makes me sad because reading is one of my favorite things to do.